UK comparison website rules do not stop you publishing "best of" lists or comparison tables. They require those lists to be honest about three things: the commercial relationships that shape them, how much of the market they cover, and how the order was decided. Under the DMCC Act, hiding that a ranking is paid, leaving out material information or presenting an incomplete comparison as the whole market can each be an unfair commercial practice. The CMA can now fine you directly for it.
This guide sets out the UK and EU rules that apply to affiliate comparison and review sites, with a practical build checklist. It is general information, not legal advice.
Why comparison and review sites are regulated
A comparison or review page is a commercial practice in its own right. It influences whether a consumer buys, and from whom. The CMA's unfair commercial practices guidance (CMA207) names price comparison websites among the businesses that can be responsible for an "invitation to purchase". It also says brand owners and influencers who promote products can be responsible for compliance. Affiliates are squarely in scope.
The main UK rules come from Part 4 Chapter 1 of the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, in force since 6 April 2025:
- Misleading actions: false information, or a presentation that deceives, about the product, its price or the nature of your relationship with the trader.
- Misleading omissions: leaving out, hiding or presenting unclearly material information the average consumer needs. That includes failing to identify commercial intent.
- Banned practices (Schedule 20): unfair in all circumstances, including paid editorial content not made clear (paragraph 12) and fake or concealed-incentive consumer reviews (paragraph 13).
The CMA can investigate, issue infringement decisions and fine up to 10% of global turnover. Our guide to CMA fines under the DMCC Act covers enforcement in detail.
What the CMA expects from comparison sites
The CMA's 2017 market study of digital comparison tools set out the CARE principles: comparison tools should be Clear, Accurate, Responsible and Easy to use. They are not statutory, but they show what the regulator regards as fair. They include:
- clearly stating when and how commercial relationships have affected the results;
- explaining any ownership links with the suppliers shown;
- clearly explaining how much of the market is covered; and
- clearly explaining how the results were ranked.
Those four points line up closely with what consumer law requires of an affiliate "best of" page.
Disclosing commercial relationships
If you earn commission from some or all of the products you compare, the average reader needs to know before relying on the comparison. Good practice looks like this:
- a short, prominent statement near the top of the page and close to the table, not only in the footer;
- clear labels on any position that is paid for or boosted, such as "Sponsored" or "Featured partner", with a short explanation of what that means; and
- no implied neutrality. Phrases like "independent rankings" or "unbiased reviews" are risky if commission levels influence the order.
See UK affiliate disclosure requirements for the wording and placement that work, and our guide to ranking transparency rules for explaining how you order results.
Are "best X" lists legal?
Yes, with care. "Best" and "top" claims are judged on what the average consumer would take them to mean:
| Wording | How it is likely to be read | What you need |
|---|---|---|
| "Our favourite cam programs" | Subjective opinion | A genuine editorial basis, plus disclosure of commercial links |
| "The 10 best dating sites in the UK" | Implies a comparison across the market | Real testing criteria, reasonable market coverage, honest ranking basis |
| "The cheapest VPN for streaming" | Objective, checkable claim | Current price evidence across the products a reader would expect you to include |
| "Ranked by our experts" | Implies expertise and an editorial process | Named methodology. No commission-driven reordering |
The ASA treats objective claims, such as cheapest, fastest or highest paying, as needing evidence held before publication. A ranking that silently reorders by EPC while claiming to be "by quality" is a misleading action.
Completeness of comparisons and misleading omissions
A comparison can mislead by what it leaves out. Watch for these common traps:
- Market coverage. If you only compare brands with affiliate programmes, say so: "We compare 14 programs we have tested. We do not cover the whole market."
- Like-for-like. Comparing one brand's promotional price with another's standard price, or a monthly plan with an annual one, distorts the result.
- Stale data. Prices, payouts and bonus terms change. Date your tables and refresh them, especially where you make price claims.
- Total price. Where you quote prices, the CMA expects mandatory fees to be included in the headline figure. Our guide to the drip pricing ban explains this.
- Material limitations. Geo-restrictions, age checks, minimum terms or rebills that would change a reader's decision should be visible in the comparison, not buried on the merchant's site.
If you compare named competitors directly, the CAP Code's comparative advertising rules also apply. Comparisons must be of like with like, objective, verifiable and must not denigrate.
Reviews, ratings and user feedback
Star ratings and user reviews are covered by the DMCC Act's banned practices. You must not publish fake reviews, commission them, or present reviews in a misleading way. That includes selectively publishing only positive ones. You must also take reasonable steps to prevent and remove fake reviews. If your site hosts user reviews of programmes or platforms, you need a written policy and a process. Our guide to the DMCC Act fake reviews ban covers the required steps.
The EU position for sites targeting Member States
The EU rules are similar, with some extra specific duties added by the Omnibus Directive (EU) 2019/2161, which has applied since 28 May 2022:
- Ranking parameters. Where consumers can search across products from different traders, the main parameters that decide the ranking, and their relative importance, are material information (UCPD Article 7(4a)).
- Paid ranking blacklisted. Showing search results without clearly disclosing paid advertising, or payment specifically for a higher ranking, is banned in all circumstances (UCPD Annex I, point 11a).
- Reviews. If you give access to consumer reviews, you must say whether and how you check they come from real users. Fake or distorted reviews are blacklisted.
See affiliate disclosure rules in the EU for the wider disclosure picture.
Comparison and review site legal requirements: a build checklist
- A disclosure statement above the fold and near each comparison table.
- A public "How we rank" or methodology page, linked from every ranking.
- Labels on every paid, sponsored or boosted position.
- A market coverage statement.
- Dates on tables, plus a review cycle for prices and terms.
- Evidence files for every objective claim (cheapest, highest payout, fastest payout).
- A user-review moderation policy and a log of removals.
- Material limitations surfaced in the table.
For building rankings that convert and stay compliant, see our practical guides to affiliate reviews that rank and the UK comparison site market.
Frequently asked questions
Can I rank affiliate partners higher because they pay more?
You can sell or award prominence, but you must clearly disclose it. In the EU, undisclosed paid ranking in search results is blacklisted outright. In the UK, it is very likely to be a misleading action or omission.
Do I have to include brands without affiliate programmes?
No, but if you leave them out, do not present the comparison as covering the whole market. A clear coverage statement solves most of the problem.
Is a footer disclosure enough?
Rarely. Disclosure must reach readers before they rely on the comparison, so place it near the table and the links.
Next steps
Write your methodology page first, then add disclosures and labels across your rankings. When you are choosing which programmes to compare, use our affiliate programs directory as a starting point. For more, browse the advertising rules section.